Business Law- Case Brief

[Name][Professor][Subject][Date]Watson v . Johnson Mobile Homes , 284 F .3d 568 (5th Circuit , 02 /27 /2002Facts : Watson d an coat for the purchase of mobile home from the defendants . The purchase see for a creed employment and a deposit of 4 ,000 . It was agreed that if the company refused Watson s application the deposit will be refunded but if the application was approved Watson s deposit will be forfeited should she decide not to continue with the purchase . When Watson s application was denied , the salesman informed Watson if she was willing to pay another 3 ,000 as a requirement in view of their poor reference work history . The Watsons refused and decided to get their money back . The Watsons family start to recover their money but it was not returned to them . Thus , the Watsons d a suit .

The jury found the defendants liable for permit out of contract , fraud and conversion and awarded the Watsons 4 ,000 in unquestionable damages and 700 ,000 in relatiative damagesIssue : 1 ) Is the Watsons were entitle to punitive damages2 ) Is the punitive damages award of 700 ,000 constitutionally excessiveHolding : 1 . Yes because the defendants acted with malevolence in refusing to return the deposit paid by the Watsons2 . No . The punitive damages award in the enumerate of 700 ,000 was constitutionally excessiveRationale : The US Court of Appeals said that there argon two tests in determining whether punitive damages should be awarded : 1 ) the defendant committed an independent...If you! want to get a lavish essay, order it on our website: BestEssayCheap.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: cheap essay